Easter Basket Stuffers Under $5 – Cute, Candy-Free Ideas
Easter is just around the corner, and if you’re putting together baskets for your kids, nieces, nephews—or a whole classroom—you’re going to love this roundup of Easter basket stuffers under $5!
Whether you’re shopping for toddlers, tweens, or teens, these sweet and practical gift ideas are candy-free, budget-friendly, and perfect for last-minute Easter prep (they ship fast!).
Why Choose Non-Candy Easter Basket Stuffers?
We love a chocolate bunny moment… but if you’re trying to skip the sugar overload this year, you’re not alone! These non-candy Easter gifts are fun, thoughtful, and can even be reused or played with long after the treats are gone.
From creative activity kits to small toys, hair accessories, and seasonal surprises, this guide has something for every bunny.
Favorite Ways to Use These Stuffers:
- Tuck a few into traditional Easter baskets for a fun, colorful surprise
- Use them to fill gift cups, favor bags, or even small boxes
- Planning a class party? These make adorable handouts for kids of all ages
- Include them as egg hunt prizes for an extra pop of excitement
- Hosting Easter brunch? These make perfect table gifts or place setting treats
Quick Tips for Making It Special:
🎀 Add printable tags or pastel ribbons (you can find some freebies in my [resources page])
🧁 Display them in cups, tiny boxes, or favor bags for extra cuteness
💌 Include a note to make each gift feel more personal
Shop the Full List Here:
Click here to shop 50+ Easter basket stuffers under $5
With so many fun and festive Easter basket stuffers under $5, you don’t need to spend a ton to make it magical. These sweet little finds are easy to order, easy to love, and easy on your budget—and they ship fast, so you’re all set for Easter morning
Happy Easter and happy shopping,
💗 Ashley Isabelle Home
